RE: Ripping Level Question (help?)

[monsterjazzlick]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

I'd list it as a compilation with "Various Artists" for the Album Artist tag (as I always do) and put their names in the Artist tags. To me, the combination of newly- and previously-released songs is still a compilation.

OK, thanks a lot. I will have a play around with that. Cheers.

[monsterjazzlick]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

If Wikipedia is correct, Corea is the only one of the four who played on all four tracks. Vitous and DeJohnette played bass and drums, respectively, on tracks 1 and 2, and Konitz played sax on tracks 3 and 4. For that reason, I would make "Chick Corea" the album artist. For the Artist tags, I would list Corea, Vitous, and DeJohnette for the first two tracks, and Corea and Konitz for the other two. The album would therefore be listed with my other "Chick Corea" albums, while the actual lineup for each track would be displayed on-screen during playback.

Thanks JH,

Yes, that's true. Corea is consistently appearing Artist.

I just took a listen and:

Track 1 = Corea, Vitous, DeJhonette,

Track 2 = Corea, Vitous, DeJhonette,

Track 3 = Corea, Konitz,

Track 4 = Corea, Konitz.

I ordered "Vol. 2" off eBay this morning and from what I can gather, Corea plays on all 3 tracks here also.

The reason I put Jack DeJohnette as Album Artist was because he was the 'organiser'.

Cheers,

Paul

[Jailhouse]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

Hi,

This album features four trios, each playing two tracks (totalling eight tracks):

https://www.discogs.com/Chick-Corea-...elease/1826239

The name of the album is (rather thoughtlessly!) the name of each pianist:

"Chick Corea, Herbie Hancock, Keith Jarrett, McCoy Tyner"

How, please, might one approach the tagging of such an album; in terms of Artist, Album Artist and Compilation?

The material features work which is either previously unissued, or else otherwise issued on (separate) albums by their respective Artists.

I still interpret the CD as being complete as whole because the title does not include terms such as 'Best Of', 'Collection', or similar.

Cheers,

Paul

I'd list it as a compilation with "Various Artists" for the Album Artist tag (as I always do) and put their names in the Artist tags. To me, the combination of newly- and previously-released songs is still a compilation.

[Jailhouse]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

I have an album ("Woodstock Jazz Festival - Vol. 1") of which I am really stuck on how to tag the Artist and Album Artist, please?

If Wikipedia is correct, Corea is the only one of the four who played on all four tracks. Vitous and DeJohnette played bass and drums, respectively, on tracks 1 and 2, and Konitz played sax on tracks 3 and 4. For that reason, I would make "Chick Corea" the album artist. For the Artist tags, I would list Corea, Vitous, and DeJohnette for the first two tracks, and Corea and Konitz for the other two. The album would therefore be listed with my other "Chick Corea" albums, while the actual lineup for each track would be displayed on-screen during playback.

[monsterjazzlick]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

Hi,

This album features four trios, each playing two tracks (totalling eight tracks):

https://www.discogs.com/Chick-Corea-...elease/1826239

The name of the album is (rather thoughtlessly!) the name of each pianist:

"Chick Corea, Herbie Hancock, Keith Jarrett, McCoy Tyner"

How, please, might one approach the tagging of such an album; in terms of Artist, Album Artist and Compilation?

The material features work which is either previously unissued, or else otherwise issued on (separate) albums by their respective Artists.

I still interpret the CD as being complete as whole because the title does not include terms such as 'Best Of', 'Collection', or similar.

Cheers,

Paul

[monsterjazzlick]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

Don't get me wrong. In case of Chick Coreas albums my folder structure would look like:

Music
- Chick Corea
-- Chick Corea Piano Improvisations Vol. 1
-- Chick Corea Piano Improvisations Vol. 2

And in case of the Woodstock albums:

Music
- Compilations
-- Woodstock Jazz Festival - Vol. 1
-- Woodstock Jazz Festival - Vol. 2

So in both cases the albums would be side a side - in case one with a real album artist in the top level folder of the album artist, and in case two with mixed album artists in top level folder 'Compilations'.

Hi Dat Ei,

Well I will see how I get along. I am not sure how often, in my personal collection, this scenario will turn up. But I do know that the next CD I am about to rip will also fall under (perhaps in your in your eyes also) a 'compilation. I will post shortly ...

Paul

[Dat Ei]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

Don't get me wrong. In case of Chick Coreas albums my folder structure would look like:

Music
- Chick Corea
-- Chick Corea Piano Improvisations Vol. 1
-- Chick Corea Piano Improvisations Vol. 2

And in case of the Woodstock albums:

Music
- Compilations
-- Woodstock Jazz Festival - Vol. 1
-- Woodstock Jazz Festival - Vol. 2

So in both cases the albums would be side a side - in case one with a real album artist in the top level folder of the album artist, and in case two with mixed album artists in top level folder 'Compilations'.

But there are plenty of ways leading to Rome... Find your own one!


Dat Ei

[monsterjazzlick]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

... a few weeks ago I was actually thinking of putting any 'Vol. 1' and 'Vol. 2' albums together. For instance:

"Chick Corea Piano Improvisations Vol. 1" and "Chick Corea Piano Improvisations Vol. 2"

would become:

"Chick Corea Piano Improvisations Vol. 1 & 2"

So instead of two albums each of 12 x tracks, you would have one album of 24 x tracks. But I decided against this in the end.

Paul

[monsterjazzlick]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

I second this. In Paul's case this is a serial of albums ("Woodstock Jazz Festival - Vol. xx) with changing artists. The single albums are kept together in one folder ('compilations') and not distributed over several artist's Folders.

Hi Dat Ei,

I may have done this method, but I have already ripped a few 'Volume' type albums now and am a bit reluctant to change method.I see your logic though and I would have followed this had I have just been starting out.

Paul

[Dat Ei]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

If I used this option (and I might), I'd then put this in ARTIST tag (so it would show up under all them)

Chick Corea;Jack DeJhonette;Lee Konitz;Miroslav Vitous

I second this. In Paul's case this is a serial of albums ("Woodstock Jazz Festival - Vol. xx) with changing artists. The single albums are kept together in one folder ('compilations') and not distributed over several artist's Folders.


Dat Ei

[monsterjazzlick]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

This question is like asking what the best flavor of ice cream is. There really is no answer. Which of the options that you lay out makes the most sense to you. For myself, when faced with this sort of thing, I pick a major artist in the group that I want to make sure the album shows up under when I browse, make them the ALBUM ARTIST, then add the long listing of players into the COMMENT tag, so that I have a record of it.

Gary,

In that case, I think I will make Jack DeJhonette the Album Artist and Chick Corea the Artist. The former is the founder of the WJF event, and the latter appears on every track, as well as composing significant material.

I would prefer to avoid having long lists of personnel. As I say, I use one or two (max.) band-members in the Artist/Album-Artist fields.

3 more discs to go and I will have ripped all Miles and Corea!

Many thanks,

Paul

[monsterjazzlick]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

I would handle this as a compilation and delete the album artist (as I do for all compilations).

Dat Ei,

Thanks a lot.

I am using the 'compilation' format for something else - slightly different. And so I don't really want to use it for more than one specific task. But I can totally see where you are coming from.

Cheers.

[garym]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

I would handle this as a compilation and delete the album artist (as I do for all compilations).


Dat Ei

If I used this option (and I might), I'd then put this in ARTIST tag (so it would show up under all them)

Chick Corea;Jack DeJhonette;Lee Konitz;Miroslav Vitous

[garym]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

This question is like asking what the best flavor of ice cream is. There really is no answer. Which of the options that you lay out makes the most sense to you. For myself, when faced with this sort of thing, I pick a major artist in the group that I want to make sure the album shows up under when I browse, make them the ALBUM ARTIST, then add the long listing of players into the COMMENT tag, so that I have a record of it.

[Dat Ei]

Re: Ripping Level Question (help?)

I would handle this as a compilation and delete the album artist (as I do for all compilations).


Dat Ei