R12 -- Ripping strategy

[HamLet]

Not sure if this makes sense, but my ideal strategy would be different depending whether the CD in accurate rip or not.

If CD is in Accurate Rip then
Phase 0: Burst Rip; If match then stop
Phase 1: Secure rip; If match then stop
Phase 2: Repeated secure rips (High security parameters, say stop after 3 secure passes in agreement, because there is a contradiction)

If CD not in accurate Rip:
Repeated secure rips (Normal security parameters, say stop after 2 secure passes in agreement)

Bottom line: I think that the UI should allow two secure strategies, depending on whether the CD is in the AR database or not or possibly depending on AR count (for instance if AR < 3 do this else do that)

Thanks! -- Ham

[Spoon]

Re: R12 -- Ripping strategy

Secure mode already does this, it will burst rip and compare with accuraterip.

[HamLet]

Re: R12 -- Ripping strategy

Indeed. And I am happy to use it. But I would prefer to try first burst mode if in AR. I think that the current program logic is:

If Burst_mode then ...
else
if in AR then
else
fi
fi

I suggest to change to

If in AR then ... else ... fi.

Hope this makes sense. Thanks!!

[LtData]

Re: R12 -- Ripping strategy

So you are suggesting it first check AR before ripping the track, and if the track is found in AR, burst rip and compare?

[EliC]

Re: R12 -- Ripping strategy

One thing that is also being ignored is the areas of the first and last track NOT covered by AccurateRip. I would like to see an option to ALWAYS use Ultra-Secure on these sectors.