ID3v2.4

[Reardon]

Hi, any plans to support (in 11.5 update, or in 12) v2.4 of the ID3 tag standard? Foobar2000 has now moved to it, curious if you might.

At a minimum, will you support reading v2.4 tags?

+R

[Spoon]

Re: ID3v2.4

It is quite funny...I have been following the recent support of id3 2.4 by fb, and his implementation only works with 1 or 2 non-main stream programs. Very odd (early versions of his programs used to remove id3v2 tags! because he didn't like them).

2.4 is far from a main stream standard, there are more problems with it right now, then not (v2.3 is supported with Unicode by practically every program).

We will probabbly add read only support.

[Reardon]

Re: ID3v2.4

Good to know you are following. Peter deserves praise for pursuing support for 2.4, but I think he jumped the gun... the standard itself just doesn't promote enough backwards compat to push implementations fw to 2.4. I do think holding at v2.3 while the Unicode stuff (UTF8 vs 16 encoding as default) gets sorted out is best.

If you support reading, that will go a long way to resolving issues.

How do you feel about the "TCMP" field hack that iTunes uses for COMPILATION flag? Are you willing to at least read and display?

+Reardon

[Spoon]

Re: ID3v2.4

R12 is not for release until a good many months, we will watch what happens with cross compatibility.