illustrate
Products            Buy            Support Forum            Registrations            Professional            About           
 

How do I know which checksum list is correct?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • donlombardo

    • Mar 2025
    • 1

    How do I know which checksum list is correct?

    Analyzing the code of whipper and audiotools to see how the accurate rip verification works. I have an album where I get this with audiotools:

    Code:
                          AccurateRip V1             AccurateRip V2
    Track           Confidence Offset Checksum Confidence Offset Checksum
    ─────────────── ────────── ────── ──────── ────────── ────── ────────
    track01.001.wav         19      0 AAA89D49         42      0 4D0F1D72
    track02.001.wav         19      0 D07C21E1         43      0 F1E2293B
    track03.001.wav         18      0 44FB6AB1         41      0 FD941F50
    track04.001.wav         19      0 BF226862         41      0 6BCBFC0F
    track05.001.wav         19      0 74C72EED         42      0 BBF9C255
    track06.001.wav         19      0 8C3E966A         42      0 7D1FFDE9
    track07.001.wav         18      0 65052495         42      0 BFBBC5FE
    track08.001.wav         18      0 768EB75A         42      0 78514E41
    track09.001.wav         18      0 4BB4DFF4         42      0 CD51398D
    track10.001.wav         16      0 5B3B8E69         43      0 4D76F728
    track11.001.wav         17      0 F14B5712         43      0 7B9BD1FC
    track12.001.wav         17      0 3346A7D6         42      0 C1026354
    and the same with whipper. I tinkered a bit with the code and got a list of all results of the album from AR.

    Code:
    [[42, '4D0F1D72'], [43, 'F1E2293B'], [41, 'FD941F50'], [41, '6BCBFC0F'], [42, 'BBF9C255'], [42, '7D1FFDE9'], [42, 'BFBBC5FE'], [42, '78514E41'], [42, 'CD51398D'], [43, '4D76F728'], [43, '7B9BD1FC'], [42, 'C1026354']]
    [[21, '727E2149'], [20, '6CB302E7'], [21, '6A9B0828'], [20, 'C57CE594'], [21, 'DCBAB351'], [21, '4EA811B8'], [21, '10669830'], [21, 'FE7A747C'], [20, '40E49067'], [20, '0AE453F2'], [20, '23EBDA73'], [20, '8DB36146']]
    [[19, 'AAA89D49'], [19, 'D07C21E1'], [18, '44FB6AB1'], [19, 'BF226862'], [19, '74C72EED'], [19, '8C3E966A'], [18, '65052495'], [18, '768EB75A'], [18, '4BB4DFF4'], [16, '5B3B8E69'], [17, 'F14B5712'], [17, '3346A7D6']]
    [[7, '54120551'], [7, 'C11C4CD3'], [7, 'F425CC96'], [7, 'C557658A'], [7, '34A0FFDC'], [7, 'E3AC5484'], [7, '1D9E4FDF'], [7, '5F0B7381'], [7, 'BDE7AE0A'], [7, '212AE7E9'], [7, 'FE759A77'], [7, '6FFFC0EE']]
    [[6, '2383D6B1'], [6, 'A4B259AD'], [6, '72FFE883'], [6, '7933255D'], [6, 'CF484349'], [6, 'FB217DD9'], [6, 'ABBB6BDF'], [6, 'BFCCAD85'], [6, '3EFC7C3C'], [6, 'EFA39656'], [6, '1E6A295B'], [6, 'D12CBB66']]
    [[5, '5885B11A'], [5, 'E3C99027'], [5, 'E803D96C'], [5, 'E213910F'], [5, '6890D326'], [5, '19926F0E'], [5, '0AA44285'], [5, '1DFF7AD9'], [5, 'C80E5911'], [5, '3B99D177'], [5, '333D674F'], [5, 'B4E2BCED']]
    [[5, '2BA074B4'], [5, '0C62892D'], [4, 'B74F201C'], [5, 'EA0B8795'], [5, '812FE9C6'], [5, 'BEFC01D8'], [5, 'B4749487'], [5, '12454C8D'], [5, 'B989C9CC'], [5, '13DE43F0'], [5, 'EF26C36B'], [4, 'BCDAD647']]
    [[3, '7BB5BC50'], [3, '955DC3B5'], [3, '66B406D9'], [3, 'E5D78343'], [3, '14DDDE4B'], [3, '89D92B09'], [3, '0404151B'], [3, 'C4443A1F'], [3, '4B8A0446'], [3, '24982A55'], [3, '5F6D7036'], [3, 'D8D400A9']]
    [[2, '2C944587'], [2, '2817D6DA'], [2, '73951F3A'], [2, '3786FB3E'], [2, '9E923D3A'], [2, '4DDA85CE'], [2, '8FAE4C79'], [2, 'FA9F0583'], [2, 'D4AD38BF'], [2, '5D1538AF'], [2, 'C58A510B'], [0, '00000000']]
    I see that there's a result between V2 and V1... Is this another album with the exact same album length and track length? or have as many as 20 people miss ripped the album the same way? How do we know the first one is the correct one?
  • Spoon
    Administrator
    • Apr 2002
    • 44873

    #2
    A different pressing, there can be 10 or more pressings stored for each disc.
    Spoon
    www.dbpoweramp.com

    Comment

    Working...