AccurateRip Pre-emphasis Bug?

[Z-Lemur]

Hi Spoon, I believe there is a bug in AccurateRip for discs ripped with varying pre-emphasis.

After the last update, my CD with a mix of tracks with and without pre-emphasis ripped perfectly. However, when having AccurateRip scan my collection, this is what comes up:



The tracks marked as having errors all had pre-emphasis decoded. Ripping log shows the tracks ripped accurately.

Hope this helps.
Z-Lemur

[Spoon]

R2025-11-12

Fixed the issue of pre-emphasis being incorrectly applied for mixed pre-emph discs.

[simbun]

The tracks marked as having errors all had pre-emphasis decoded. Ripping log shows the tracks ripped accurately.

Surely the decoded tracks won't verify will they, given they're now different to the CD?

This is one of the reasons I keep a copy of the original PRE/HDCD disc rips

[Spoon]

AccurateRip happens before pre-emphasis, so it would not effect verification.

[simbun]

AccurateRip happens before pre-emphasis, so it would not effect verification.

Z-Lemur is verifying post-rip with PerfectTunes.

[Spoon]

Then it would

[simbun]

Then it would

fail to verify?

Unless you're assuming that the following options are set:

• CD Ripper: CD Ripper Options > Meta Data & ID Tag > Options > Write ID Tags: AccurateRip Result
• PerfectTunes: Use AccurateRipResult from ID Tag

In other words, the audio isn't checked just the tags.