title
Products            Buy            Support Forum            Professional            About            Codec Central
 

Optiarc ODDs - HIGHER QUAILTY ?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • MONITOR

    • Feb 2015
    • 2

    Optiarc ODDs - HIGHER QUAILTY ?

    I have noticed that the forum or dbpoweramp (?) does does seem to like Optiarc ODDs. Optiarc have now been sold to Philips/ Lite-on so the Optiarc models are obsolete.

    Having built a new PC for audio, and starting re-ripping to a 500Gb SSD using an older (well used) cheap (~£10) 2011 Optiarc ODD, I then wondered if anything better could be bought. A search found that the more expensive (£37) Optiarc 5280S-CB-PLUS has claims to higher quality: Japanese (Sony?) design, better components… So I bought one not expecting it to be better or even much different. I also compared the sound to that from a Pioneer 2011 BD writer (lightly used). However, it is gives a very different sound to both the older ODDs.

    The sound from 5280S seems more pure, fuller and it gives a better grip/space. Now with computer audio someone told me this may be introduced noise and jitter (like found with not sorting the usb like to DAC. I am now listening using a SoTM card. The 5280S appears to “rattle” more smoothly when running fast!?

    I see that one person posting did mention getting an Optiarc 5280S above. So what is the learned opinion on this please?

    Also I have tried ripping fastest and slow (4X) but cannot hear much if any difference. Again, what is learned opinion on this please?
  • garym
    dBpoweramp Guru

    • Nov 2007
    • 5907

    #2
    Re: Optiarc ODDs - HIGHER QUAILTY ?

    Originally posted by MONITOR
    I have noticed that the forum or dbpoweramp (?) does does seem to like Optiarc ODDs. Optiarc have now been sold to Philips/ Lite-on so the Optiarc models are obsolete.

    Having built a new PC for audio, and starting re-ripping to a 500Gb SSD using an older (well used) cheap (~£10) 2011 Optiarc ODD, I then wondered if anything better could be bought. A search found that the more expensive (£37) Optiarc 5280S-CB-PLUS has claims to higher quality: Japanese (Sony?) design, better components&*8230; So I bought one not expecting it to be better or even much different. I also compared the sound to that from a Pioneer 2011 BD writer (lightly used). However, it is gives a very different sound to both the older ODDs.

    The sound from 5280S seems more pure, fuller and it gives a better grip/space. Now with computer audio someone told me this may be introduced noise and jitter (like found with not sorting the usb like to DAC. I am now listening using a SoTM card. The 5280S appears to &*8220;rattle&*8221; more smoothly when running fast!?

    I see that one person posting did mention getting an Optiarc 5280S above. So what is the learned opinion on this please?

    Also I have tried ripping fastest and slow (4X) but cannot hear much if any difference. Again, what is learned opinion on this please?
    a bit perfect rip is a bit perfect rip, independent of drive. That's the beauty of ACCURATERIP. Also, it appears you may have been misled by some bad information that is typical of certain audiophile sites that get many things about digital audio very wrong. I suggest you do some searching and reading at hydrogenaud.io site.

    Comment

    • MONITOR

      • Feb 2015
      • 2

      #3
      Re: Optiarc ODDs - HIGHER QUAILTY ?

      I have read many forums including Hydrogen. Some help with why I hear the differences would be more helpful.

      Comment

      • Spoon
        Administrator
        • Apr 2002
        • 44583

        #4
        Re: Optiarc ODDs - HIGHER QUAILTY ?

        AccurateRip uses CRCs, if the CRC matches between rips (with different drives) then the audio is 100% identical, no ifs, no buts.
        Spoon
        www.dbpoweramp.com

        Comment

        Working...

        ]]>