Building an AccurateRip of a disc from multipl drives and/or discs

[EliC]

If you are unable to get an accuraterip of a disc in a drive, the data from that rip is saved, including information on bad sectors, C2 errors, etc. The disc is then placed in a second drive. Because each drive reads discs a little differently it may be able to get an accuraterip or it may be able to recover some frames the first drive could not. This would allow users with multiple drives to potentially get an accuraterip that no single drive alone could get.

If the user has access to more then one copy of the disc, the a second disc could be used. If other copies have a different pressing offset, dBpoweramp could use the pressing offset of the first disc to read the data required to re-build the first disc accurately.

[sredmyer]

Re: Building an AccurateRip of a disc from multipl drives and/or discs

This functionality would be especialy useful to pro ripping outfits. Even more so if one were able to create such functionality as a DSP.

This dove-tails nicely with another of your requests here

http://forum.dbpoweramp.com/showthread.php?t=17353

I would certainly be creating a DSP to provide this functionality in my particular workflow if such as DSP SDK were available.

[EliC]

Re: Building an AccurateRip of a disc from multipl drives and/or discs

I don't know if you would need a DSP for this. I think much of the required info is already generated and stored with the current ripper. You would just need to save all of this info between rips for inaccurate/error rips for attempts in other drives.

[sredmyer]

Re: Building an AccurateRip of a disc from multipl drives and/or discs

I don't know if you would need a DSP for this. I think much of the required info is already generated and stored with the current ripper. You would just need to save all of this info between rips for inaccurate/error rips for attempts in other drives.

True but unless Spoon wants to take on this development, the only way we mere mortals could implement such functionality would be through a DSP. I believe this DSP could be written using information currently available (in the extraction log) and run as a "Run External" DSP but it would be far easier to write if a DSP SDK were provided that included access to that information. Parsing text files can be a real PIA when the structure of the file is content dependant and largely undocumented.

[EliC]

Re: Building an AccurateRip of a disc from multipl drives and/or discs

Yes, it probably could be done with a DSP if spoon opened the development. The feature request was actually in hopes of spoon developing this. Its a tool that would help set dBpoweramp even further ahead of other software. The question is always what sets one piece of software apart, especially when you have to pay for one and not the other. Spoon already has the best meta-data system (though hopefully he continues to improve it), but what can set R14 apart and make it worth the upgrade or new purchase? I think this is a feature that can really help dBpoweramp to be a leader.

[EliC]

Re: Building an AccurateRip of a disc from multipl drives and/or discs

others would like these features as well:

http://www.hydrogenaudio.org/forums/index.php?showtopic=76739&hl=

[ksvane]

Re: Building an AccurateRip of a disc from multipl drives and/or discs

Would be an awesome feature! :D

[Oliviander]

Re: Building an AccurateRip of a disc from multipl drives and/or discs

Would be an awesome feature! :D

Yesss that would be it !!!