error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

[MartinBar]

Hello

I am getting the message "error ripping to ..... error opening file, check no other program has it open [cidecoder::writeidtags]" when ripping with the Multiencoder on a quad core system.

It is occurring sporadically but on most CDs on around 1-4 tracks on the CD

As far as I can tell by experimentation the cause seems to be that the Windows Search Indexing service has temporarily opened the file and this locks out dbpoweramp from updating the tags - re-ripping the tracks almost always works first time.

When I says seems I ripped 6 CDs and all but one had an error on at least one track. I then paused the Windows Search Indexing service and ripped another 6 CDs with no errors. So not conclusive but highly indicative.

I had seem previous advice that security software can cause these symptoms and have excluded the relevant folders form scanning

Any ideas welcome on how to get round this as pausing Windows Search Indexing service seems overkill - a longer delay in dbpoweramp would be one solution but there is no user option to modify this

kind regards

Martin

[Spoon]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

We shall take a look at this again, the issue can be when ripping a track, it is ripped, it is tagged, then it is retagged to add accuraterip data, we have retry loops which wait to get access to the file, it could be these need making longer.

[MartinBar]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

We shall take a look at this again, the issue can be when ripping a track, it is ripped, it is tagged, then it is retagged to add accuraterip data, we have retry loops which wait to get access to the file, it could be these need making longer.

Thanks - this all makes sense as I did notice that there was plenty of metadata in the files where the problem occured.

As a short term workaround I have excluded the rip destination from Windows indexing - in the longer term making the loop wait longer would be better.

All the best

Martin

[acyates]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

I am consistently getting this error with CDs on secure rips to FLAC. The CDs are in excellent condition and will rip successfully using J River (secure rip). It also seems to cause tagging errors on repeats of this message. Above does not make sense to me. Can anyone please explain how to cure this error.

Tony

[Spoon]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

Try ripping to a location which is not indexed by other players (ie not Music folder), then after ripping move the files to music folder.

[acyates]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

Thank you for your quick response. Just tried a CD and it worked without errors.

Tony

[acyates]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

I have followed your suggestion about location.

I have now tried 7 CDs. 5 rips OK. 2 rips with repeated errors. Taking one CD as an example 'Error opening file', repeated x8. 'dDecoder: Write ID Tags'. On tracks 1,3,5,6,7,8.
So 6 tracks ok, 6 tracks with above error.
Am I correct in saying the rip was successful, but the tagging was failing on 6 tracks.
Was the tagging successful after 8 tries?

I also tried reripping a failed CD. It failed again on different tracks.

This is on a well maintained Windows 7 pc, with automatic Microsoft updates and Microsoft security software. Task manager confirms no other program running. I recently upgraded to the latest version of dbpoweramp.



Tony

[Spoon]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

Those tracks where it gives an error, if you browse to one of them, right click and try to change one of the ID Tags (for example add a '1' to the end of Title), does it save the tag?

[acyates]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

Which program do I use to browse and at what stage?
Do you mean the saved file? (in the temporary music directory)

Tony

[Spoon]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

Browse using Windows File Explorer, to where ever it was ripped to.

[acyates]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

No. Title change of track is not saved. For example on track 2.

Error ripping to FLAC, 'Track 1' to 'C:\Users\Public\Public DBPA Music\Mark Knopfler\Golden Heart\01 Mark Knopfler - Darling Pretty.flac'
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]

Error ripping to FLAC, 'Track 2' to 'C:\Users\Public\Public DBPA Music\Mark Knopfler\Golden Heart\02 Mark Knopfler - Imelda.flac'
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Unable to tag file 'C:\Users\Public\Public DBPA Music\Mark Knopfler\Golden Heart\02 Mark Knopfler - Imelda.flac'

Error ripping to FLAC, 'Track 4' to 'C:\Users\Public\Public DBPA Music\Mark Knopfler\Golden Heart\04 Mark Knopfler - No Can Do.flac'
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Unable to tag file 'C:\Users\Public\Public DBPA Music\Mark Knopfler\Golden Heart\04 Mark Knopfler - No Can Do.flac'

Error ripping to FLAC, 'Track 6' to 'C:\Users\Public\Public DBPA Music\Mark Knopfler\Golden Heart\06 Mark Knopfler - Don't You Get It.flac'
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]

Error ripping to FLAC, 'Track 7' to 'C:\Users\Public\Public DBPA Music\Mark Knopfler\Golden Heart\07 Mark Knopfler - A Night in Summer Long Ago.flac'
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Error opening file, check no other program has it open. [clDecoder::WriteIDTags]
Unable to tag file 'C:\Users\Public\Public DBPA Music\Mark Knopfler\Golden Heart\07 Mark Knopfler - A Night in Summer Long Ago.flac'

[Spoon]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

The posted log is from CD Ripper, what happens if you browse with Windows Explorer to that file, right click on it >> Edit ID Tags, change one tag and click Ok

[acyates]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

I did exactly that, but also included the log for information. I confirm I used Windows Explorer and edit tag, changed title, and the change was not saved.

[Spoon]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

Did it say 'Unable to write ID Tags for:'?

[acyates]

Re: error ripping to error opening file, check no other program has it open.

No. It accepted the edit but did not save it on saying ok