title
Products            Buy            Support Forum            Professional            About            Codec Central
 

Discogs, Russian CDs, submitting to freedb?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • idiotprogrammer

    • Nov 2012
    • 13

    Discogs, Russian CDs, submitting to freedb?

    I am a heavy user of your software. Overall, it kicks ass!

    (I'm actually writing a book on music collecting and plan to write a section specifically about this software).

    Here's a situation I face often.

    I have an Asian or Russian CD which I rip. Either dbpoweramp can't find disc information through the known sources. Or, it finds it through FREEDB, which often has the wrong encoding on it. Because I know Russian (barely!) I can often type metadata by hand (very slowly!), but I have noticed cases where DISCOGS has the CD listed while the others don't.

    For example, this CD http://www.discogs.com/%D0%98%D1%80%...elease/2601476

    Just wondering why dbpoweramp doesn't also search this database. Are there licensing/cost issues? I know foobar2000 lets you do this (a plugin, I thinK). Is there a way that I could import the metadata through a text file?

    In this particular case I was able to use Foobar2000 to query discogs, and it found a correctly encoded metadata set.


    Finally, another question. I often have to manually type in metadata manually for my CD. Often the CD is not in any of the databases (not just for Russian or international stuff, but obscure US stuff as well). Dbpoweramp lets you submit changes to freedb, but as far as I can tell, it has no way to submit a new CD via dbpoweramp to freedb. Am I missing something? Or was this a design decision?
  • Spoon
    Administrator
    • Apr 2002
    • 44505

    #2
    Re: Discogs, Russian CDs, submitting to freedb?

    To look up discogs you need a artist + release name...which you would not have if the CD was not in any other databases.

    You can submit with the meta drop menu >> Submit To >>
    Spoon
    www.dbpoweramp.com

    Comment

    • Porcus
      dBpoweramp Guru

      • Feb 2007
      • 792

      #3
      Re: Discogs, Russian CDs, submitting to freedb?

      But Spoon, improving metadata once the release is pinned down, that is the amazing thing about PerfectMeta, and with Discogs you usually get much better data for a given release - composer credit, featuring artists, etc.

      (True, you cannot use Discogs to find another matching album to choose between, but PerfectMeta does not in any case know whether I listen to gospel or black metal.)

      Comment

      • idiotprogrammer

        • Nov 2012
        • 13

        #4
        Re: Discogs, Russian CDs, submitting to freedb?

        A few replies:

        First, on the meta drop down, you have "Submit Changes to" not "Submit to" . In my version I am working with, I can only edit existing metadata and resubmit them. I can't submit a new record. (Am I mistaken?)

        In the particular case I was speaking about, Freedb did have a record, but the encoding was wrong. discogs had the record with correct encoding.

        Comment

        • Spoon
          Administrator
          • Apr 2002
          • 44505

          #5
          Re: Discogs, Russian CDs, submitting to freedb?

          If you type a new record you should be able to submit.
          Spoon
          www.dbpoweramp.com

          Comment

          • Porcus
            dBpoweramp Guru

            • Feb 2007
            • 792

            #6
            Re: Discogs, Russian CDs, submitting to freedb?

            Originally posted by idiotprogrammer
            In the particular case I was speaking about, Freedb did have a record, but the encoding was wrong.
            You cannot submit corrections to freedb (that's why you see the same rock record with better spelling filed in the Classical or Misc database - people rather submit the right metadata to the wrong base, because they cannot correct the one which is already there).

            Allmusic does, on their web site, solicit corrections, but I do not know whether they actually read correction suggestions submitted from dBpoweramp.

            Comment

            • idiotprogrammer

              • Nov 2012
              • 13

              #7
              Re: Discogs, Russian CDs, submitting to freedb?

              I created another thread about the freedb submission problem http://forum.dbpoweramp.com/showthre...-to-freedb-etc

              Comment

              • Henkjan

                • Oct 2010
                • 24

                #8
                Re: Discogs, Russian CDs, submitting to freedb?

                Originally posted by Porcus
                But Spoon, improving metadata once the release is pinned down, that is the amazing thing about PerfectMeta, and with Discogs you usually get much better data for a given release - composer credit, featuring artists, etc.
                lookup can be similar to how the album art is found, that also requires that the artist and album are identified. Speaking of album art: Discogs is an excellent source of album art

                Comment

                • Porcus
                  dBpoweramp Guru

                  • Feb 2007
                  • 792

                  #9
                  Re: Discogs, Russian CDs, submitting to freedb?

                  Originally posted by Henkjan
                  similar to how the album art is found, that also requires that the artist and album are identified
                  Hah! There your excuse goes down the drain, Spoon :D

                  Comment

                  Working...

                  ]]>