Bob Dylan's Tempest - Not Accurate Rip?

[David W]

I just purchased Tempest, the new Bob Dylan CD, and ripped it through my ususal setup with CD Ripper. After a few attempts, I was surprised to see the results of "secure" and not "accurate" as I would expect for a new, widely available CD. I almost always get an accurate rip unless the CD is potentially damaged or it is really obscure. That is not the case here. Any thoughts as to why this might be happening?

Here is the result from the first track as an example:

Information ripping to [Multi Encoder], 'Track 1' to 'C:\Users\Harris\Music\Bob Dylan\Tempest\01 Bob Dylan - Duquesne Whistle.IGNORE'
Track 1: Ripped LBA 0 to 25776 (5:43) in 2:36. Filename: C:\Users\Harris\Music\Bob Dylan\Tempest\01 Bob Dylan - Duquesne Whistle.IGNORE
Secure [Pass 1 & 2, Ultra 1 to 3]
CRC32: C1BD117B AccurateRip CRC: 97469E09 (CRCv2) [DiscID: 010-00165929-00b876cc-8b10100a-1]

Thanks!

-David

[Spoon]

Re: Bob Dylan's Tempest - Not Accurate Rip?

The database is updated once every 4 weeks...perhaps it has not appeared online yet.

[bort]

Re: Bob Dylan's Tempest - Not Accurate Rip?

I'm having the same problem for disc 1 of the Bob Dylan Mono Recordings (discs 2 through 9 work fine). The collection was released in 2010 so the problem is not that the CD is too new. CTDB finds and verifies the disc successfully:

[CUETools log; Date: 5/5/2013 1:23:56 AM; Version: 2.1.4]
[CTDB TOCID: je9mfsFqN40_wGYu8vW3yFLjOm8-] found.
Track | CTDB Status
1 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
2 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
3 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
4 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
5 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
6 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
7 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
8 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
9 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
10 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
11 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
12 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
13 | (22/22) Accurately ripped
[AccurateRip ID: 00115f40-00afd667-a308b30d] disk not present in database.

[Spoon]

Re: Bob Dylan's Tempest - Not Accurate Rip?

You would have to try disc 1 in EAC or dBpoweramp to make sure the AccurateRip ID is correct.

[bort]

Re: Bob Dylan's Tempest - Not Accurate Rip?

You would have to try disc 1 in EAC or dBpoweramp to make sure the AccurateRip ID is correct.

EAC says the tracks are not found in AccurateRip. Here is the TOC of disc 1:

Track | Start | Length | Start sector | End sector
---------------------------------------------------------
1 | 00:00:00 | 01:41:28 | 0 | 7602
2 | 01:41:28 | 03:21:45 | 7603 | 22722
3 | 05:02:73 | 02:41:26 | 22723 | 34823
4 | 07:44:24 | 03:10:21 | 34824 | 49094
5 | 10:54:45 | 02:22:19 | 49095 | 59763
6 | 13:16:64 | 03:25:64 | 59764 | 75202
7 | 16:42:53 | 02:53:65 | 75203 | 88242
8 | 19:36:43 | 01:47:16 | 88243 | 96283
9 | 21:23:59 | 02:37:02 | 96284 | 108060
10 | 24:00:61 | 05:19:67 | 108061 | 132052
11 | 29:20:53 | 02:20:62 | 132053 | 142614
12 | 31:41:40 | 02:44:15 | 142615 | 154929
13 | 34:25:55 | 02:42:18 | 154930 | 167097

[Spoon]

Re: Bob Dylan's Tempest - Not Accurate Rip?

For this CD there are 7 different releases...

http://musicbrainz.org/release/52bcfeba-f829-36dd-b418-e412cc9e3a5a/discids

Try dBpoweramp please also, it can check across ARv2 CRCs (cross pressing in AccurateRip) which CueTools or EAC cannot do.

[Spoon]

Re: Bob Dylan's Tempest - Not Accurate Rip?

Looking up the disc in the first post, it is now present in AccurateRip.

[bort]

Re: Bob Dylan's Tempest - Not Accurate Rip?

For this CD there are 7 different releases...

http://musicbrainz.org/release/52bcfeba-f829-36dd-b418-e412cc9e3a5a/discids

Try dBpoweramp please also, it can check across ARv2 CRCs (cross pressing in AccurateRip) which CueTools or EAC cannot do.

dBpoweramp says "Not in AccurateRip" for all tracks, although it finds the metadata info fine. I am ripping the actual retail CD (not a burned copy). It's hard to believe that this CD would not be in AccurateRip because the other 7 discs of the 8-disc set are all in AccurateRip with scores of ~25 for each track, so the only logical conclusion is that something is wrong with the AccurateRip info for this disc. I used EAC to submit the result of my rip -- can you check that you received it successfully? The AccurateRip ID is 00115f40-00afd667-a308b30d.

[bort]

Re: Bob Dylan's Tempest - Not Accurate Rip?

For this CD there are 7 different releases...

http://musicbrainz.org/release/52bcfeba-f829-36dd-b418-e412cc9e3a5a/discids

Try dBpoweramp please also, it can check across ARv2 CRCs (cross pressing in AccurateRip) which CueTools or EAC cannot do.

dBpoweramp just says that the tracks are not in AccurateRip. I submitted my results to AccurateRip (through EAC), but I think there might be something wrong with the AccurateRip database for this disc, because all of the other discs in the Original Mono Recordings box set verify with AR scores of ~25 per track. The AccurateRip ID for the disc is 00115f40-00afd667-a308b30d.