Read the first review on Amazon for the item linked below.
Bottom line : 2 CD set contains 9 JS Bach cantatas conducted by Jürgen Jürgens. For BWV 018 though, a different performance (Harnoncourt) of the same cantata was used in error.
I waited a little over a year to order this with the hope that it would be fixed.
I go my copy today. The cantata in question is on disk 2. I insert disk 1 and Perfect Meta retrieves the data. I put in disk 2 and it is not recognized. I own a CD that officially has the recording used in error, and can vouch that disk 2 of the copy I have that is not recognized by Perfect Meta does not have the wrong recordings, so Warner made good on their promise to fix this.
I can, of course, enter the meta data for the fixed CD and submit the changes. But I am curious what Perfect Meta retrieves if someone puts in the original CD that has the wrong recording of BWV 018. Likely all of the meta data sources show the performance of all of the cantatas as being conducted by Jürgen Jürgens. How does one go about correcting the various databases to at least alert would rippers that they have a disk with the wrong recording on it.
Any ideas/suggestions?
Bottom line : 2 CD set contains 9 JS Bach cantatas conducted by Jürgen Jürgens. For BWV 018 though, a different performance (Harnoncourt) of the same cantata was used in error.
I waited a little over a year to order this with the hope that it would be fixed.
I go my copy today. The cantata in question is on disk 2. I insert disk 1 and Perfect Meta retrieves the data. I put in disk 2 and it is not recognized. I own a CD that officially has the recording used in error, and can vouch that disk 2 of the copy I have that is not recognized by Perfect Meta does not have the wrong recordings, so Warner made good on their promise to fix this.
I can, of course, enter the meta data for the fixed CD and submit the changes. But I am curious what Perfect Meta retrieves if someone puts in the original CD that has the wrong recording of BWV 018. Likely all of the meta data sources show the performance of all of the cantatas as being conducted by Jürgen Jürgens. How does one go about correcting the various databases to at least alert would rippers that they have a disk with the wrong recording on it.
Any ideas/suggestions?
Comment