Tweet
I'd like to try this again, this time in this forum.
To start, I'm not using Accuraterip v2... just the one that's always come with EAC 0.99 pb5. Now, here's what I'm wondering about: On some very short tracks I get "0/0 No matches" even when all the other tracks give me something like "Accurately ripped 03/03". I want to know how short the song has to be before Accuraterip just decides not to accept it.
The last time I asked this, back at Hydrogenaudio in January, I got a few guesses: if it's 50 frames, if it's 450 frames, if the track is silent, and if it's a bad rip. None of these apply to me. I've ripped a CD that gives me all results as "Accurately ripped 03/03" except for the last 4 tracks, which give me "0/0 No matches". These tracks are 30, 14, 5, and 7 seconds long. So, three of them are greater than either of the frame amounts guessed (6 seconds), none of them are silent, and there's just no way all 3 people who ripped this CD got got the same thing on every track except the those tracks by some magical coincidence, where we all happened to get completely different results. I do test and copy, and both CRCs match up for the tracks every time and the CD is spotless. Sure, I considered that sometimes 2 people will get different results and so it will sure up as "0/0 No matches", but there's a third person. That this third person did not get any of the same CRCs on any of those tracks as either of the other two people... no. And, there is only one pressing of this CD ever.
Now... does anyone know the cutoff point for when a track does not show up in the database? It disturbs me quite a bit. For your use, if it helps you: 0040d0aa-0513949b-8b0df41c. It's the Disc ID for the Accuraterip results.
To start, I'm not using Accuraterip v2... just the one that's always come with EAC 0.99 pb5. Now, here's what I'm wondering about: On some very short tracks I get "0/0 No matches" even when all the other tracks give me something like "Accurately ripped 03/03". I want to know how short the song has to be before Accuraterip just decides not to accept it.
The last time I asked this, back at Hydrogenaudio in January, I got a few guesses: if it's 50 frames, if it's 450 frames, if the track is silent, and if it's a bad rip. None of these apply to me. I've ripped a CD that gives me all results as "Accurately ripped 03/03" except for the last 4 tracks, which give me "0/0 No matches". These tracks are 30, 14, 5, and 7 seconds long. So, three of them are greater than either of the frame amounts guessed (6 seconds), none of them are silent, and there's just no way all 3 people who ripped this CD got got the same thing on every track except the those tracks by some magical coincidence, where we all happened to get completely different results. I do test and copy, and both CRCs match up for the tracks every time and the CD is spotless. Sure, I considered that sometimes 2 people will get different results and so it will sure up as "0/0 No matches", but there's a third person. That this third person did not get any of the same CRCs on any of those tracks as either of the other two people... no. And, there is only one pressing of this CD ever.
Now... does anyone know the cutoff point for when a track does not show up in the database? It disturbs me quite a bit. For your use, if it helps you: 0040d0aa-0513949b-8b0df41c. It's the Disc ID for the Accuraterip results.
Comment