HDCD Rip Issue - Roxy Music "Avalon"

[akopperl]

Today I ripped The Roxy Music "Avalon" CD - SACD / CD Hybrid version. The CD version includes HDCD. However, when I ripped the CD - it only ripped it as a 16 bit recording. When I rip, I have the HDCD DSP on at all times.

I have other CDs with HDCD that ripped as 24 bit recordings. Any advice on why it did not work with "Avalon"? Also, will the 24 bit rips sound just as good as playing back the CD through an HDCD decoder?

Thanks

[Spoon]

If your right click on the columns and switch on the technical column, does that highliht the cd as HDCD?

[akopperl]

No, it does not display HDCD in the Technical column. The disc does state that it is an HDCD disc. I guess the disc may be mislabeled.

If a disc does have HDCD, will it sound the same ripped to 24 bits as it does when played back through an HDCD compatible player.

Thanks,

Anthony