Originally Posted by
GBrown
I'm not sure if you mean the new rip doesn't sound any louder than the original by just using Replaygain (apply), or if you mean the volume did not increase after the first DSP was applied then layering in the second with the Normalize function.
They are very different in how they work. But both should exhibit a difference from before and after, whether they are each applied on their own, or together (where there should be a cumulative effect). Regardless, I still recommend you only apply one of the two DSPs, just use one baseline file and apply each DSP and save them as separate files. Then you can A/B these to determine which you prefer.