title
Products            Buy            Support Forum            Professional            About            Codec Central
 
Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 123
Results 31 to 39 of 39

Thread: CD Drive Accuracy 2019

  1. #31
    dBpoweramp Enthusiast
    Join Date
    Jun 2020
    Posts
    77

    Re: CD Drive Accuracy 2019

    Quote Originally Posted by schmidj View Post
    My experience has been that most external drives are not very good. Besides accuracy problems, most are slow. When ripping to my laptop, I use an "internal" drive with an external SATA power supply and a SATA to USB converter. Works well.
    Does this mean that you are better off with a laptop that has an internal drive (preferably Bluray-capable?) rather than buying an external drive?

  2. #32
    dBpoweramp Guru
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    New York
    Posts
    421

    Re: CD Drive Accuracy 2019

    No, the built in internal laptop drives are, in most cases no better than the external ones. The good drives, in my experience, are the "internal" 5 1/4 full height desktop drives. Use them with a USB to SATA or IDE adapter as appropriate for that drive, and an external power supply with a USB port on your laptop. You don't need an external case, just treat the connectors on the back with reasonable care. Hunt around for used drives salvaged from desktop computers that have been retired. With an assortment of drives, you'll find which ones read damaged CDs the best.

    Unfortunately, the variety of DVD drives is rapidly shrinking. My (limited) experience with Bluray burning drives has been that they aren't particularly good at reading scratched or otherwise damaged CDs. I had better luck with DVD drives.

  3. #33
    dBpoweramp Enthusiast
    Join Date
    Jun 2020
    Posts
    77

    Re: CD Drive Accuracy 2019

    This is the one I have: https://www.amazon.com/Pioneer-BDR-X...1397602&sr=8-8

    I noticed that the original post lists a few Pioneer drives in the good drives category, but mine is a bluray and that worries me that it's not going to be good at reading damaged discs.

  4. #34
    dBpoweramp Enthusiast
    Join Date
    Dec 2017
    Posts
    50

    Re: CD Drive Accuracy 2019

    I'm considering buying a new DVD/CD Writer. Any idea when the 2020 list will be released please?

  5. #35

    Re: CD Drive Accuracy 2019

    Hi

    Wondered whether you can help. I have installed dbpoweramp on two PC's - one with a LG HL-DT-ST GH24NSD0 24 x DVDRW Internal DVD Burner which seems to have a good accuracy of 98% from your listings on a second machine I have a Liteon eBAU108-11 USB slimline external drive which dosent' appear on you lists. Is this because it not very good or not enough people have used it as a device.

    The only reason I asking is that when i RIP a CD on the GH24 I get no errors and I do get errors on a variable number of frames on the ebau108-11. The Liteon drive is brand new. Is this because it's less tolerant of problems (I suspect that there really is an issue on this CD as I had issues when I stuck it in the player in the car).

    Cheers

  6. #36

    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    11

    Re: CD Drive Accuracy 2019

    There are some comments here about internal drives vs external. I don't know about all of them, but I've just started using this one, and other than the fact that it doesn't have the required 4000 submissions to make to Top Drives list, it does seem to be accurate enough:

    Drive: Dell - DVD+--RW DW316 (88 users): Submissions: 481 accurate, 3 inaccurate, 99.3802 % accuracy

  7. #37

    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    11

    Re: CD Drive Accuracy 2019

    One more comment, I had glommed on to the iHAS124 F as a drive to get. It's an internal drive that I use with an external "enclosure" that takes care of all the connections. The accuracy, speed, etc, was fine. That F drive only last 18 months or so though, and then it started digging/scratching into my discs. Figured that out after it had trashed 2 CDs. When I tried to get another W, I couldn't, so I got an F. The F drives aren't great for accuracy though, and the one I put in about a year ago, already is failing to recognize all the CDs I insert into it. So the reliability/longevity of those iHAS124 drives isn't great. I have a 3rd one I bought, but now I'm trying the Dell DW316 external drive now.

    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 A (72 users): Submissions: 2156 accurate, 132 inaccurate, 94.2308 % accuracy
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 B (585 users): Submissions: 15349 accurate, 619 inaccurate, 96.1235 % accuracy
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 C (119 users): Submissions: 2510 accurate, 118 inaccurate, 95.5099 % accuracy
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 D (119 users): Submissions: 1936 accurate, 32 inaccurate, 98.3740 % accuracy
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 E (196 users): Submissions: 4292 accurate, 176 inaccurate, 96.0609 % accuracy
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 F (226 users): Submissions: 2095 accurate, 62 inaccurate, 97.1256 % accuracy ..... <<==
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 W (206 users): Submissions: 9756 accurate, 72 inaccurate, 99.2674 % accuracy ..... <<==
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 Y (260 users): Submissions: 8856 accurate, 210 inaccurate, 97.6837 % accuracy

  8. #38

    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    11

    Re: CD Drive Accuracy 2019

    One more, sorry. I started with this one, and I still have two of them, but I decided to try the iHAS124 drives because they're faster. I do like the Plextors though, but they're not as accurate as a well functioning iHAS124 F or the Dell DW316:

    Drive: PLEXTOR - CD-R PX-W4824A (178 users): Submissions: 8029 accurate, 131 inaccurate, 98.3946 % accuracy

    I do note though that if the accuracy of the Dell DW316 external drives holds as the database gets more submissions, that would be the most accurate of the drives that I've personally tried.

  9. #39

    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    11

    Re: CD Drive Accuracy 2019

    Quote Originally Posted by Gaspar View Post
    One more comment, I had glommed on to the iHAS124 F as a drive to get. It's an internal drive that I use with an external "enclosure" that takes care of all the connections. The accuracy, speed, etc, was fine. That F drive only last 18 months or so though, and then it started digging/scratching into my discs. Figured that out after it had trashed 2 CDs. When I tried to get another W, I couldn't, so I got an F. The F drives aren't great for accuracy though, and the one I put in about a year ago, already is failing to recognize all the CDs I insert into it. So the reliability/longevity of those iHAS124 drives isn't great. I have a 3rd one I bought, but now I'm trying the Dell DW316 external drive now.

    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 A (72 users): Submissions: 2156 accurate, 132 inaccurate, 94.2308 % accuracy
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 B (585 users): Submissions: 15349 accurate, 619 inaccurate, 96.1235 % accuracy
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 C (119 users): Submissions: 2510 accurate, 118 inaccurate, 95.5099 % accuracy
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 D (119 users): Submissions: 1936 accurate, 32 inaccurate, 98.3740 % accuracy
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 E (196 users): Submissions: 4292 accurate, 176 inaccurate, 96.0609 % accuracy
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 F (226 users): Submissions: 2095 accurate, 62 inaccurate, 97.1256 % accuracy ..... <<==
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 W (206 users): Submissions: 9756 accurate, 72 inaccurate, 99.2674 % accuracy ..... <<==
    Drive: ATAPI - iHAS124 Y (260 users): Submissions: 8856 accurate, 210 inaccurate, 97.6837 % accuracy
    Misstated. The ** W ** is the one I started with, then went to the F. W is good for accuracy, F not so much. Neither seems to be very reliable though. At least the ones I have had.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •