dbpa CDRipper & CD pre-emphasis detection

[JayNYC]

To the experts here....

I'm running dbpa ref v16. CD-Ripper supports identification of CD pre-emphasis:

(a) via TOC only
(b) via Subcode Q only
(c) via both TOC and Subcode Q
(d) other _____________

thanks

[mville]

Re: dbpa CDRipper & CD pre-emphasis detection

Out of interest, why does it matter how CD Ripper detects pre-emphasis?

[Spoon]

Re: dbpa CDRipper & CD pre-emphasis detection

It is via the toc only.

It matters as there are a handful of discs which have tracks which are pre-emphasis but not indicated in the TOC.

[mville]

Re: dbpa CDRipper & CD pre-emphasis detection

It is via the toc only.

It matters as there are a handful of discs which have tracks which are pre-emphasis but not indicated in the TOC.

OK. So do you know of any other tool that detects such discs, so we can manually add the pre-emphasis tag?

[Oggy]

Re: dbpa CDRipper & CD pre-emphasis detection

OK. So do you know of any other tool that detects such discs, so we can manually add the pre-emphasis tag?

EAC, but I believe the last version that did is V0.95 prebeta 3.

This is from May 2003.

[mville]

Re: dbpa CDRipper & CD pre-emphasis detection

EAC, but I believe the last version that did is V0.95 prebeta 3.

This is from May 2003.

Thank you. Do you know of any other tool that detects any pre-emphasis discs, post rip?

[JayNYC]

Re: dbpa CDRipper & CD pre-emphasis detection

not post rip, but according to

http://wiki.hydrogenaud.io/index.php?title=Comparison_of_CD_rippers

CueRipper on Windows and XLD on MacOS supports both TOC and subcode detection

[JayNYC]

Re: dbpa CDRipper & CD pre-emphasis detection

It is via the toc only.

It matters as there are a handful of discs which have tracks which are pre-emphasis but not indicated in the TOC.

Wanted to bump this with another casual request to add SubCode PE detection to dbpa CD ripper.