Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

[paul poon]

I have copied the screen with the rip status below here :



Does this matter ?

[garym]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

I have copied the screen with the rip status below here :

[ATTACH=CONFIG]801[/ATTACH]

Does this matter ?

Probably ok (as it reports secure). How many passes have you set? but can you try ripping on a different drive to see if results are the same.

[mville]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

Ideally, you'd try another drive as garym suggests. You could also try giving the CD a wipe clean, and re-ripping. On several occasions this has worked for me.

[paul poon]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

Thanks for the reply.
I've set "Minimum Ultra Passes: 1 Maximum Ultra Passes: 2 End After Clean Passes: 1"

This is a new DVD-ROM bought 3 days ago.
The old one is probably broken.

I don't mind if it doesn't matter.

Below here I've copied another CD with the same problem :

[paul poon]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

Thanks for the advice garym and mville.
I'll try wash the CD with soap to see whether it'll work.

[paul poon]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

sorry to let you know that ripping doesn't work out after washing the CD with soap :

[mville]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

sorry to let you know that ripping doesn't work out after washing the CD with soap

It is not an issue. I have many CD tracks that are not accuraterip accurate, but are secure.

[paul poon]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

Thanks for the reply.

If flac format and accurate flac format is just the same I don't mind.

By the way, I don't know the difference between accurate and secure.

I guess accurate rip is more important than secure (?)

Thanks for letting me know that it's not an issue.

I guess I won't take it as an error now.

[garym]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

Thanks for the reply.

If flac format and accurate flac format is just the same I don't mind.

By the way, I don't know the difference between accurate and secure.

I guess accurate rip is more important than secure (?)

Thanks for letting me know that it's not an issue.

I guess I'll not take it as an error now.

AccurateRip match just means that your secure rip matches one or more other people's rip of same CD. So it is just a powerful piece of evidence that your secure rip is really secure. A secure rip without an AR match is still very likely secure. It just doesn't have that extra bit of evidence of comparison to others rips.

[mville]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

By the way, I don't know the difference between accurate and secure.

I guess accurate rip is more important than secure

Something to read:

AccurateRip

dBpoweramp CD Ripper Setup Guide

[paul poon]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

Thanks a lot for the explanation garym.
Thanks a lot for all the information mville.
I'll read it.

[Spoon]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

In this instance I am quite certain your rip for track 1 has errors, all the other tracks verified with a high confidence. No CD drive on the market can self detect errors 100% of the time, a secure result is the drive thinking it is 100% correct, but accuraterip tells a different story here.

[paul poon]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

Thanks spoon for the explanation.
I'll go to the library to borrow the CD (if there's any) and try ripping on my CD-ROM.
If there's no error in the track, my CD must be bad (?)

[paul poon]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure



/In this instance I am quite certain your rip for track 1 has errors/

You're right, Spoon !

I borrowed a CD from the library and I rip only track 1 and it's accurate.

[paul poon]

Re: Rip Status = x AR (34) V secure

Thanks garym and mville for the suggestion written below here :
/but can you try ripping on a different drive to see if results are the same. /

I borrowed a CD from the library and I rip only track 1 on the same DVD-ROM and it's accurate.
I guess that there's problem with the CD.