View Full Version : HTOA and Accuraterip

04-08-2008, 12:26 AM
I now have 3 discs with confirmed HTOA but I have noticed there are no accurate rip info for these tracks.

I am assuming that is simply because HTOA is new to r13 and also the scarcity of HTOA discs.

I am curious if accurate rip does, or will be, supporting the HTOA tracks.

I hope it does/will because HTOA is notoriously difficult to extract, and with accurate rip backing up extractions, it will make it alot more re-assuring once the database starts to populate more.

For reference, the 3 discs I have are:

queens of the stone age - songs for the deaf
songs in the key of X - various (xfiles related)
blind melon - soup

The first 2 had a large numbe of AR (for the normal tracks), while the 3rd had a handful. None of them had HTOA in AR.

I have ripped the discs successfully with 2 different drives:

04-08-2008, 03:06 AM
HTOA is not in AccurateRip, as many drives would not rip it consistantly.

04-08-2008, 05:18 AM
HTOA is in in AccurateRip, as many drives would not rip it consistantly.

Guess you mean "not in AccurateRip".

Teknojnky: Try re-ripping with dBp, see if you get same CRC (green colour).

04-08-2008, 08:32 AM
Most drives will not be able to rip HTOA, but for those that can, is there any reason not to support it in AR (or maybe AR2)?

04-08-2008, 08:43 AM
Discs are identifed on TOC and trackcount, you cannot shove a track 0 in there.


Yes sorry, HTOA is not in AccurateRip.